Moccasins. I had a pair of these in college (soft soled and everything), but then forgot about them. After spending hours and hours shopping for shoes that I could wear around town running errands, etc., that didn't make my feet sad (and failing) I went back to these. I bought them at Shoebuy.com but Zappos carries them too. They arrived today. They were just about wide enough when I was barefoot under them, but with socks they are cut a little narrow. Knowing the amount that leather stretches I think they'll be fine in a few days.
From Drop Box
From Drop Box