Minimal Shoes Aren't Great

Refoman

Barefooters
May 8, 2013
60
114
33
64
Albuquerque New Mexico
I was active on this site a few years ago, but fell away. The short version of a long story is that after transitioning to full-on barefoot running, I decided it was not for me. I began to run exclusively in minimal shoes such as the New Balance Minimus and Merrell Vapor Glove. I did fairly well, up to running a half-marathon. Very recently I starting running again after a long break. Something I saw or read rekindled my interest in barefoot running. Since my mileage was low, I decided it would be a good time to again try the VFFs I wore while transitioning to barefoot and since I had been in minimal shoes so long, the transition wouldn’t take long. I started to build some (small) mileage in the VFFs, not thinking much about them other than remembering how much I liked them. They are very comfortable and apparently my form in them is good. I ran, what for me is, a crazy-fast mile-and-a-half in them this week.


Recently, I read or heard somewhere that one should rotate their running shoes. I know, I know, you real barefooters don’t understand this. Anyway, I decided to “rotate” to the Merrells after running in the VFFs. I was quite surprised as to how much they—the most “minimal” shoes I have ever owned—changed my foot strike. Within a few steps, I realized how heavily I was heel-striking and had to consciously and continuously change form to accommodate that. This isn’t an issue for the VFFs or I would have certainly felt it on my crazy-fast mile-and-a-half.


The moral of this long-winded post is to say that even “minimal” shoes significantly change running form.
 
  • Like
Reactions: happysongbird
I remember years ago having a conversation at "that other place" about how minimal shoes, even as minimal as VFFs, change running form and have the potential to cause people to do too much too soon (TMTS) and losing a few "friends" over that statement. I still stand by it.

Welcome back! :barefoot:
 
I'm certainly starting to notice even running in Vapor Gloves or Xeroes my form isn't as good as it is when completely unshod. I recently also got a pair of Luna Mono 2.0s for running on the gravel roads near my house and I swear my left ankle acts up a bit more in those. I also developed a huge blister on the front of my right arch because I don't have the straps adjusted quite right. Thankfully that blister doesn't keep me from running barefoot at all.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Barefoot TJ
Recently, I read or heard somewhere that one should rotate their running shoes. I know, I know, you real barefooters don’t understand this.

I understand the reasons why this is recommended but they're all about cushioned, motion-control shoes and don't really apply to minimalist shoes. It's supposedly so the foam can have time to recover and spring back in one pair of shoes while you run in the other.

There *might* be a case for rotating minimalist shoes just for perhaps cross-training your feet as you've pointed out how your form can change even from one shoe to the next but, of course, you should be running with the same form regardless of footwear or lack thereof.

But, yeah, the rotating shoes thing is typically just more BS borne out of a foolish reliance on cushioned, motion control shoes.
 
And of course they want us to believe that a pair of cushioned running shoes will only last 500 miles and should be replaced often...to brainwash us and get more money out of us. Actually, wearing down all that cushion and rubber helps to make the shoes better, so replacing them undoes any good running in them ever did. Ha!
 
  • Like
Reactions: trevize1138
I cringe at the posts over at /r/running because 1/2 of them are "have you gone to a running store? They'll look at your feet, tell you how bad you pronate and sell you expensive shoes to weaken your feet!"

I also remember every time I got new shoes in the bad old days my feet would hurt because I had to "break in" the new shoes. I'm now guessing it was my feet fighting to move and do their thing and getting sore because the stiff new shoe was preventing them from doing it. Would have been better sticking with that old pair that allowed my feet to move.
 

Support Your Club

Forum statistics

Threads
19,151
Messages
183,611
Members
8,696
Latest member
Barefoot RPS

Latest posts