I don't really have much to add yet Lee. Just trying to give my own minimalist routine some time to see how it affects me. I have kinda stolen your ideas on big lifts, pyramiding, plyo, and put my own twist on it. My goal right now is weight loss and not performance like the two of you. I am also trying to increase flexibility and get my body to stay injury free.
Would be interested in your approach/routine, if you have a minute.
Yes we did and likewise, it helps me to talk it over to really weed through all the info and see different perspectives.
I like the plan and think I will do something very similar but possibly only two days a week. I know you probably have it in another workout but don't forget dedicated ab work unless you are just skipping it? I am also wondering if you might want to skip one big leg lift and do power cleans? If you are feeling like you are not getting enough recovery. Or is that thrust cleans?
Also give snatch grip high pulls a whirl too I have been getting some good results similar but better to shrugs. With a little less tension on my neck. And if you are doing loaded carries its very similar.
Yah, I really feel like I'm understanding all the different possibilities better now. There's like a million fitness sites all telling you that they've discovered the secret, but I guess through our discussion and reading around that I kind of know what's going to work for me. I'm really happy to have discovered box jumps, and appreciate your pushing me to do more squats, and focus on the big lifts, among other things.
We'll see how well the knees hold up to three big lower body lifts per week. I've tried to mitigate the stress a bit by making one of the squat days front squats, which I can do higher rep/lower weight if need be. I'm also alternating the deadlifts between BB and Trap Bar. We'll see. Yesterday I did everything at about 80 percent: Squat and Bench Press at 175 instead of 225, Rows at 150 instead of 200, skipped the Dips and did Landmines at 100 instead of 150. I did three sets of 3-5 reps for each exercise after initial warmups. I'm easing into this for the first week or two, to see how my body reacts. If it's too much I will either modify or go back to my previous routine, which only has two big lower body days and works every other body part/area once a week. I don't want to lay off doing my maxes for too long.
Power Cleans would be an excellent substitute, and I like that they're more plyometric than squats or deadlifts. They seem to aggravate my left shoulder a bit however, so I don't know how much I can push them, so I don't know if they can be the centerpiece of a third weekly workout. I think I've also been doing them with too much shoulder rotation, and not enough shrug, which could be part of the problem. I think I begin to flip the bar before I get to this stage:
I'll try practicing with an unloaded bar. I know last year I was doing them at 175 without issue, so the recent shoulder irritation is probably unrelated. It reappeared while shoveling this winter. I would love to get my power cleans up to around 225. I've uploaded a revised routine with the Power Cleans always falling on Friday, the day before my long run. Something to consider . . .
Even if I eventually bail on this routine with three workouts per week of squats or deadlifts, either substituting power cleans or incorporating one workout per week without a lower body exercise, it will serve as a nice four-week phase in which I push the squats a bit more. Of the three big lifts--bench, DL, and squat, the squat is my weakest. I should be able to do 250-275 I think, instead of 225, and will soon I hope, especially with this extra attention. The goal is still to get my dl up to 350, and my squat up to 300. My bench is already OK at 225. Those feel like my natural plateaus after a couple of years of nearly monthly gains.
With my left shoulder issue, I'm a bit leery of doing the snatch grip high pulls. But I may reintroduce the upright row as part of my row routine at some point. The thrusters would be done from full kneeling position, since I have a low garage ceiling. This will also work the back more. For the same reasons, the DB snatches will probably be done from a split or half-kneeling position.
The dedicated ab work occurs in the plyometric/mobility component, on the second page of the uploaded file. Here's how the (idealized) schedule would play out, given in minutes for each of the four fitness components:
It averages out to about 90 minutes per day. With roughly
50% Running
25% ST
15% Plyo/Mo
10% Flexibility
My initial impression after yesterday's workout is that this minimalist but full-body approach, or some modification of it, will work well, either as a periodization, or as a permanent routine. I've never done periodizations before, but I could, for example, do this one month, using more of a straight-set approach, and then the following month do more of one-big-lift-per-workout routine in which I focus more on pushing the max, using my modified drop-set approach. We'll see. I like the idea of working the whole body though. Together with my plyo/mo workout on st off-days, this means that I'll be working the whole body pretty much everyday. I pretty sure I'll be shedding some pounds soon if I can keep it up!
I really like the minimalism of alternating one workout with a lower-body push and mid-body push/pull (Squats/Bench/Row), and then a lower-body pull with an upper-body push/pull (Deadlift/Press/Pulldown). It's conceptually elegant. The one thing I don't like is having to mess with setting up equipment so much as I move from one exercise to another, but it's not that big a deal.
I forgot to mention that your goals of 400 DL, 225x10 Bench, and 21-minute 5k sound like really good goals. As you know, I've been running a 5k route around my neighborhood this month, close to every day, and have thought about timing it once in a while once it warms up a bit more. I'd be happy with a 24-minute finish, or even just 27 minutes at this point. Last summer I got below 9mm pace on a 10 k run, but haven't repeated that since. 400 DL would be awesome. You'd be approaching advanced level at that point.